A Bad Theory of Truth in Fiction

Abstract

William D'Alessandro has recently argued that there are no implicit truths in fiction. According to the view defended by D'Alessandro, which he terms explicitism, the only truths in fiction are the ones explicitly expressed therein. In this essay, I argue that explicitism is incorrect on multiple counts. Not only is the argument D'Alessandro gives for it invalid, but explicitism as a theory of truth in fiction fails drastically to account for a number of phenomena that are crucial to our understanding and interpretation of fiction, such as pragmatic implicatures and speech acts occurring in fiction, psychological profiles of fictional characters, and fictional truths determined by literary conventions.

from #ORL-AlexandrosSfakianakis via ola Kala on Inoreader http://ift.tt/2mxQQg6